UPDATE April 22:
As of now the charcoals have it narrowly (4-3 including 3 who have read ak, and so whose votes carry a certain weight) but there's a paucity of comments explaining why.
Please, nay-voters, make your arguments! If it's just plain ol' conservatism, "I like it the way it is," that doesn't cut it. I'd never improve anything if I thought that way. But maybe you've got a point that I don't know or haven't thought of. I want to hear it!